So was he right to get sacked?
Legally? If he breached the internal rules of the company, don’t know if he should have been sacked, but absolutely he should face disciplinary consequences.
Morally? Yep. On this, I’m afraid I’m a ‘no tolerance’ fella. For all the ‘it was consensual’ it can never been
deemed consensual because of the disparity in the power dynamic. The other person (and I’ve known it same sex as well) is junior to the senior person. Outsiders can’t
possibly know whether the other person truly believed it was consensual or whether they felt they
had to sleep with the boss in order to keep their job. No one can know that. And so the only way is ‘no sexual relationship between v senior staff and more junior staff.’
As I’ve mentioned before, I was once a financial director. Not a huge company; about 50 staff, £16m turnover a year.
I was asked what it was like, going from financial controller (the number 2 job in the finance dept) to the financial director’s job, the number 2 job in the
company, under chief exec.
I said two major differences:
1/ timescales (now responsible for making sure the company was still around in two years, say)
2/
every woman in the company was now off-limits. Because there wasn’t a single one I didn’t outrank.
(And though I never had an issue with one of
my junior staff seeing another person in the company at the same level, I had to
know about it, so - for example - I could ensure one didn’t approve the others’ expenses.)
Yeah, it’s never a good idea. And the few times it works out fine are pebbles on a mountainside compared to the avalanche of examples when it’s a disaster, either at the time, or when it ends.